LOGIN DASHBOARD

    Explainers

    6 MIN READ

    PM Oli made three false claims

    Deepak Adhikari, September 3, 2020, Kathmandu

    PM Oli made three false claims

      Share this article

    Fact-checking PM's claims defending his government’s COVID-19 response and overall performance.

    (The Record)

    This article was originally published in South Asia Check – an independent, non-partisan, non-profit initiative by Panos South Asia, aiming to promote accuracy and accountability in public debate

    Speaking on Janata Janna Chahanchhan talk show on Prime Times Television on August 29, Prime Minister KP Oli defended his government’s COVID-19 response and highlighted his government’s achievements in the last two and a half years. The one-hour 46-minute interview has been viewed more than 350,000 times until September 2, and is trending at number 6 in Nepal on YouTube in Nepal.

    Among several claims made by Prime Minister Oli, South Asia Check has examined three.

    First claim

    “Currently, we are conducting 23,000 to 24,000 PCR [polymerase chain reaction] tests daily. This is not a small matter.”

    At a daily press briefing a month ago, spokesman at the Ministry of Health and Population Dr Jageshwar Gautam said the government was working to enhance its capacity to conduct more than 18,000 PCR tests daily.

    As per the latest data, over 13,000 PCR tests were carried out on August 26, the highest single day tests so far. About a month ago, on July 31, the government had recorded highest PCR tests (10768) till then. That record on PCR tests was broken on August 16 when a total of 12,247 tests were conducted.

    Date

    Total PCR tests

    August 23, 2020

    8,026

    August 24, 2020

    10,234

    August 25, 2020

    11,327

    August 26, 2020

    13,253

    August 27, 2020

    12,629

    August 28, 2020

    10,229

    August 29, 2020

    10,971

    Source: Ministry of Health and Population

    Therefore, Oli’s claim about PCR tests is exaggerated.

    Second claim

    “The government provides all necessary treatment to COVID-19 patients without distinguishing between rich and poor. The government bears the entire treatment costs. Isn’t this extraordinary? None of our neighboring countries have done this. They don’t have this kind of arrangement.”

    Several Indian states have provided free medical treatment for COVID-19 patients. Indian state of Andhra Pradesh has announced that designated hospitals will treat COVID-19 patients, especially those living below the poverty line, for free and the government will pay the medical bill, according to a report in the Hindustan Times. Government hospitals in some states provide free medical treatment. In some Indian states, people’s medical insurance covers the treatment for COVID-19. Several Indian state governments have fixed prices for COVID-19 treatment.

    Nepal’s northern neighbor China has said in a white paper that COVID-19 patients (confirmed or suspected) including those who have received subsidies from state finance for any medical bills not covered by basic medical insurance, serious disease insurance, or medical assistance fund are provided free treatment, according to the state-run Xinhua news agency.

    On the basis of these news reports, Prime Minister Oli’s claim that Nepal’s neighbors don’t provide free COVID-19 treatment is false.

    Third claim

    “We have built 700,000 houses and handed them over (to the beneficiaries) over the last two and a half years.”

    Oli mentioned these figures while claiming that his government had made significant progress in post-earthquake reconstruction. But according to the National Reconstruction Authority, the number of houses completed so far is 576,623 and more than 700,000 houses are under construction.

    Therefore, Oli’s claim that his government built and handed over 700,000 houses during his tenure is wrong.

    :::::::::


     



    author bio photo

    Deepak Adhikari  Deepak Adhikari is the editor of South Asia Check, a fact-checking organization.

      



    Comments

    Get the best of

    the Record

    Previous Next

    YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

    Opinions

    3 min read

    Betraying ourselves

    Monalisa Maharjan - August 6, 2019

    The Nepalization of our diverse languages is erasing our memory and links to our landscape, and disrupting the continuity between our past and the present.

    Explainers

    6 min read

    Mahara may be fired - and his case could go nowhere

    The Record - October 3, 2019

    The sexual violence allegation against Mahara is a test for the government, CPN and state institutions.

    Timeline

    6 min read

    2017 Nepal news retrospective

    The Record - December 31, 2017

    COVID19

    News

    3 min read

    Kathmandu Valley extends prohibitory orders until September 9

    The Record - September 2, 2020

    The decision was made by authorities since the coronavirus has continued to rise at a steady pace for the past week

    COVID19

    Features

    8 min read

    An industry under siege: the media during Covid-19

    Ashok Dahal - March 14, 2021

    While journalists suffered through pay cuts and layoffs, media houses lost billions in revenue, financially squeezing the media industry.

    Features

    9 min read

    Disenfranchised – millions of Nepalis have no voting rights

    Marissa Taylor - March 21, 2022

    Despite the outsized impact that migrant workers have on Nepal, they are still unable to vote in elections as Nepal has no provisions for absentee voting.

    Perspectives

    6 min read

    When women who speak up face lawsuits

    Shreya Joshi - August 6, 2020

    Legal hurdles have prevented the #MeToo movement from taking off in Nepal

    Features

    3 min read

    Red revolt continues unabated against the red party’s chief

    The Record - December 29, 2020

    Nepal and Prachanda say they will continue protesting until Parliament gets restored

    • About
    • Contributors
    • Jobs
    • Contact

    CONNECT WITH US

    © Copyright the Record | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy