LOGIN DASHBOARD

    News

    6 MIN READ

    In major blow to Oli, Supreme Court rules House dissolution unconstitutional

    The Record, February 23, 2021, Kathmandu

    In major blow to Oli, Supreme Court rules House dissolution unconstitutional

      Share this article

    The Supreme Court, on Tuesday, reinstated Parliament and ordered that it meet within 13 days.

    (The Record)

    Two months after Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli dissolved the House of Representatives, the Supreme Court has ruled that the dissolved Parliament be reinstated and that the first meeting of the House meet within 13 days. 

    “The Parliament has been reinstated,” Bhadrakali Pokharel, spokesperson for the Supreme Court, confirmed to The Record. 

    Rajan Bhattarai, advisor to the prime minister, said that Oli would respect the court’s decision and was holding political consultations on the next steps forward. 

    Ever since Oli decided to dissolve the Lower House on December 20, a decision that was swiftly approved by President Bidhya Devi Bhandari, much ink had been spilled over whether his actions were constitutional. Bhandari had cited Article 76 (1), (7) and Article 85 of the constitution while approving of Oli’s House dissolution. Article 76 (7) speaks directly to the dissolution of the House, stating: “In cases where the Prime Minister appointed under clause (5) fails to obtain a vote of confidence or the Prime Minister cannot be appointed, the President shall, on recommendation of the Prime Minister, dissolve the House of Representatives and appoint a date of election so that the election to another House of Representatives is completed within six months. states that the prime minister.”

    Legal experts, including four former chief justices of the Supreme Court, however, have expressly stated that the 2015 constitution does not allow the prime minister to dissolve the House as Article 76 (7) only applies in cases where the prime minister cannot be appointed in the first place. Most of the drafters of the constitution who spoke to The Record said that they had refused to provide the prime minister with the prerogative to dissolve the House, a clause that had been present in previous constitutions, keeping in mind Nepal’s enduring political instability. 

    “This [verdict] has put an end to the autocratic steps that Oli had taken,” Raman Shrestha, former Attorney General and one of the lawyers to petition Oli’s House dissolution, told The Record. “Now that Parliament has been reinstated, it will become functional once the Speaker calls a session. The constitution, which was written by the people, has come back to life.”

    The decision -- taken by a constitutional bench led by Chief Justice Cholendra Shumsher Rana -- puts to rest speculation over which way the Supreme Court would lean but it also throws Nepal’s near future into further uncertainty. Prime Minister Oli had called for mid-term elections in Spring, which will now not happen. Faced with a hostile Parliament, which was preparing to table a vote of no confidence against Oli before its dissolution, the prime minister will be cornered and more likely to resort to desperate gambits. 

    The Supreme Court verdict is also a victory for Oli’s opponents in the ruling Nepal Communist Party -- Madhav Kumar Nepal and Pushpa Kamal Dahal. Nepal called the verdict a “victory of the people” on social media. The Dahal-Nepal combine had launched street protests, prompting Oli to respond with his own show of strength. A politically-unaffiliated ‘Nagarik Andolan’ had also sprung up to oppose Oli’s ‘unconstitutional steps’. 

    Read more: Oli sacrifices the constitution to save his skin

    Now that Oli’s dissolution has been overturned, there is confusion over the many constitutional appointments that the Oli government made in the interim. The Oli government had made appointments to numerous critical constitutional bodies, including Prem Kumar Rai to lead the powerful Commission for the Investigation of Abuse of Authority. Most recently, on February 19, the government had removed Tilak Pariyar as chief of Province 2 and appointed Oli acolyte Rajesh Jha ‘Ahiraj’ in his stead. 

    According to advocate Om Prakash Aryal, any ordinance that made the appointments will have to be tabled before Parliament when it sits and if it is rejected, all appointments will be overturned. 

    “The appointments will not be cancelled ipso facto,” Aryal said. “The Parliament can reject the ordinance, which will overturn the appointments, or the appointments can also be overturned because they require a Parliamentary hearing.”

    Legal experts have welcomed the Supreme Court verdict as a victory over unconstitutionality. 

    “The constitution and constitutionalism has prevailed. This verdict sends a strong message that no one is above the law and it has also earned the judiciary the trust of the public,” said advocate Raju Chapagain. “Now, the prime minister can either resign on moral grounds as his decision has been overturned by the court. If he does so, then the first meeting of Parliament will begin the process of electing a new prime minister as per Article 76 of the constitution. If he does not resign, Prime Minister Oli will have to face a vote of no confidence.”

    Most political analysts that The Record spoke to were optimistic and expressed a rekindling of faith in Nepal’s judiciary. 

    “Parliament reinstatement has reinstated the trust in democracy,” said Prakriti Bhattarai Basnet, founding chairperson of Political Literacy for Women. “This decision is a win for democracy, a win for all Nepalis. As a young citizen of this country, this decision has replanted hope in us.”

    The Supreme Court ruling Prime Minister’s Oli actions unconstitutional is certain to be welcomed by many across the country, but there is also a renewed sense of apprehension about the Oli faction’s response. 

    The constitution has prevailed; whether political stability will follow is -- of yet -- difficult to tell. 

    ::::::

    This article has been updated to correct Tilak Pariyar's removal as chief of Province 2, not Province 1.



    author bio photo

    The Record  We are an independent digital publication based in Kathmandu, Nepal. Our stories examine politics, the economy, society, and culture. We look into events both current and past, offering depth, analysis, and perspective. Explore our features, explainers, long reads, multimedia stories, and podcasts. There’s something here for everyone.



    Comments

    Get the best of

    the Record

    Previous Next

    YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

    Features

    Explainers

    Longreads

    16 min read

    How peaceful is Nepal really?

    Pranaya Sjb Rana , Ishita Shahi - March 9, 2021

    What does peace mean to the Nepali people, especially the country’s many minority groups? The Record explores, and answers.

    Features

    13 min read

    Further crippling the yarsagumba economy could worsen hunger in Nepal’s mountain regions

    David Ellis Johnson - June 14, 2020

    The ban on this year’s harvest due to Covid-19 threatens livelihoods and risks furthering the nation’s food insecurity

    COVID19

    News

    3 min read

    Covid19 Roundup, 16 April: Police brutality on the rise, an exodus of the hungry & increased border security

    The Record - April 16, 2020

    A daily summary of Covid19 related developments that matter

    COVID19

    News

    3 min read

    Nepal finally approves a vaccine for emergency use

    The Record - January 15, 2021

    The government will need more vaccines and the funds to buy them to meet its immunisation goals

    3 min read

    A Dalit village during the lockdown

    Sujan Shrestha - May 12, 2020

    The residents of Dalit bastis in Siraha are more worried than the economic implications of the measures taken to contain the coronavirus than about the virus

    Perspectives

    8 min read

    Oli's follies

    Roshan Sedhai - February 7, 2020

    The Prime Minister’s habit of bulldozing decisions through party and government has alienated all his allies

    Interviews

    12 min read

    From politics to poetry: Kedar Man Vyathit

    Uttam Kunwar - May 5, 2020

    Vyathit was a prolific poet who wrote in Nepali, Newari and Hindi languages

    Features

    5 min read

    Lessons we don’t learn from history

    The Record - December 15, 2020

    Determined to crush Maoist rebels instead of seeking a political solution, Oli is repeating the same mistakes Deuba made in the 90s which resulted in a decade-long people’s war

    • About
    • Contributors
    • Jobs
    • Contact

    CONNECT WITH US

    © Copyright the Record | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy