LOGIN DASHBOARD

    Features

    5 MIN READ

    Data Reveals Local Elections a Disaster for Gender Equality

    Bhola Paswan, October 24, 2017, Kathmandu

    Data Reveals Local Elections a Disaster for Gender Equality

      Share this article

    2 percent elected to head rural or urban municipalities, 1 percent elected to head wards

    (Bijay Kumar Mahato)

    In May, June and September 2017, Nepal conducted local elections to elect a total of 35,041 local representatives across 753 local levels including 6 metropolitan cities, 11 sub-metropolitan cities, 276 municipalities and 460 rural municipalities. 

    This was the first local election since the promulgation of the 2015 constitution, and came two decades after the last one held during the civil war. It also took place against the backdrop of discontent regarding the new constitution, particularly on federalism and state restructuring. Since representation of minorities is the primary goal of Nepal’s state restructuring, in this series of data stories, we begin by analyzing the results of the election for newly created local bodies. 

    Why is this important? The 2015 constitution of Nepal, Article 38(4) gives women the right to proportional representation in all levels of governance. The 2011 census shows that women make up 51.5% of the population of Nepal. The Election Commission had mandated that 40.4% of all nominees seats be reserved for women, and this included the rule that between mayor and deputy mayor, and between chair and deputy chair of rural municipalities, parties had to field one woman candidate. Similarly, at the ward committee level with four member seats and one ward chair, the parties had to have at least two women ward members, one of them had to be a Dalit.

    Even with quotas, men outnumber women

    Despite the 50% quota for mayor, chair and deputy positions, and two of the four ward member seats set aside for women, men still outnumber women in the 35,041 thousand local government positions. 

    Gender distribution comparison between newly elected local representatives and national population

    Women were elected to very few top positions

    The results show that women won as deputies instead of mayors and chairpersons. Only 2% of the mayor and chair positions out of the total 753 went to the women, while 91% of the deputy positions went to women. 

    Representation of women in the mayor, deputy mayor, chair and deputy chair positions.

    One percent of ward chairs are women

    For the posts without mandated gender quotas (the two open competition ward committee member seats and the ward chair seat) women’s representation is negligible. Out of the 13,484 non-quota ward member positions, only 2% went to women. Similarly, out of the total 6742 ward chair seats, women won only 1%. This is the lowest representation of women across the various local government posts.

    Women’s representation in the ward chair and ward member (open) posts

    Ethnic composition of women representatives

    Ethnic composition of women local representatives

    A total of 14,339 women are part of the local government. Among them, 47.4% are Dalits, 23.5% are Khas Arya women, 19.9% are Janajati, 8% Madhesi, and 1.3% Muslim. Seven out of 263 mayor seats were won by women, among them 6 are Khas Arya, and 1 is Madhesi. Similarly, the Chair position had 11 women, of which 6 were Khas-Arya and 5 Janajati.  Dalits appear significant, but outside of the Dalit women quota, their presence barely registers.

    Ethnic composition of women representatives across the various local posts: mayor, deputy mayor, chair, deputy chair, ward chair, and the ward member positions of (i) ward member open, (ii) woman ward member (excluding dalit woman seat) and (iii) dalit woman ward member seat.

    Madhesi women are not represented as well as Hill women; similarly Terai Dalits (who got 23%) are not as well represented as Hill Dalits (who got 77%) in the Dalit Woman Ward Member post.

    Ethnic distribution across parties

    Dalit women have a large presence among women representatives, and this is because of the Dalit Woman Ward Member post. If we only consider the other seats, Khas Arya and Janajati women have the biggest presence in the mainstream parties. The smaller parties that lean towards identity have high representation of Madhesi and Muslim women but minimal presence of Khas and Janajati women.  

    Ethnic composition of women representatives by party

    The Dalit seat

    The 6567 Dalit Woman Ward Member seats filled by the parties show the smaller parties prioritizing Madhesi Dalit women over Hill Dalits.

    Distribution of Pahad and Terai Dalit for the Dalit woman ward member seat across parties

    Political affiliations of women representatives

    Political affiliation of women representatives by ethnicity

    When we analyze the data in terms of political affiliation per ethnicity, we see that the vast majority of Khas, Janajati and Dalit women representatives who have been voted in are from the three major parties: UML, Nepali Congress, and Maoists. Madhesi and Muslim women representatives got their ticket from a wider range of parties.

    Women’s marginalization continues

    Results of this local election show that women are able to fill a certain number of posts because of the quotas, but they rarely enjoy positions of power, whether it’s the mayor of a town, chair of a rural municipality, or the chair of a ward. Men dominate both in terms of numbers and executive positions.  

    The representation of women belonging to different ethnicities is not uniform either. Dalit women have a large presence, again because of the Dalit Women Ward Member post, but they have negligible presence among non-Dalit quota seats, and are completely absent from the three executive positions of mayor, chair and ward chair. In the non-Dalit quota seats, Khas Arya women dominate, followed closely by Janajatis, and then Madhesis, Dalits and Muslims. 

    In conclusion, our analysis shows that despite the promise of state restructuring, women continue to be denied political power at the local level. 

    All charts by Supriya Manandhar



    author bio photo

    Bhola Paswan  Bhola Paswan is a senior reporter with The Record.



    Comments

    Get the best of

    the Record

    Previous Next

    YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

    Features

    5 min read

    What’s next for Prime Minister Oli?

    Bhadra Sharma - February 24, 2021

    With his House dissolution ruled unconstitutional by the Supreme Court, Oli is scrambling to find ways to secure his position.

    News

    4 min read

    Prime Minister Oli has lost the vote of confidence. What does that mean?

    The Record - May 10, 2021

    Oli has effectively become a caretaker prime minister and will need to make way for a new government. But is the political drama prudent in the midst of a pandemic?

    The Wire

    News

    7 min read

    Freed from bondage, ready to vote

    Peter Gill - May 8, 2017

    Seventeen years after emancipation, many ex-kamaiyas prepare to vote in local elections for the first time

    Opinions

    3 min read

    What next for federalism in Nepal

    Amish Raj Mulmi - December 7, 2017

    The campaigns revealed that either the idea of provinces hasn’t yet filtered down to the street level, or the federal project has been deliberately weakened

    Perspectives

    8 min read

    Oli's follies

    Roshan Sedhai - February 7, 2020

    The Prime Minister’s habit of bulldozing decisions through party and government has alienated all his allies

    Perspectives

    6 min read

    Province 2 and Sudurpaschim show how federalism can bring about political stability

    Sovit Subedi - February 16, 2021

    Federalism appears to be working in exactly the two places—with distinct regional identities—where it was most likely to work.

    Features

    2 min read

    How did Madhesis fare in the local elections, and who won among them?

    Bhola Paswan - November 21, 2017

    Prominent posts tend to fall on the socially and politically more privileged Yadavs and Terai Brahmin-Chhetris

    Features

    5 min read

    Deuba’s reluctance to join the anti-Oli protests could severely impact Nepal’s democracy

    The Record - December 28, 2020

    Even those within Deuba’s own party think he is building an alliance with the PM

    • About
    • Contributors
    • Jobs
    • Contact

    CONNECT WITH US

    © Copyright the Record | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy